The All-Index
All holdings

UnitedHealth Group (OptumRx)

UNHBearish

Provides health insurance plans and pharmacy benefit management services through UnitedHealthcare and Optum.Yahoo Finance ↗unitedhealthgroup.com

1 take · first discussed May 17, 2025

Stock since first call
+28.8%
$315.89$406.79
Current call
Bearish+28.8%
since May 17, 2025✗ wrong so far· stance 390d old
anchored May 17, 2025 · as of Jun 11, 2026

The tape vs. the takes

Every call, plotted at the price the day they made it.

$413.00$244.67FFriedberg — bear — May 17, 2025May 19, 2025Jun 11, 2026
letter = host · click for the quote

The discussion

The only host thesis provided comes from Friedberg, who holds a bearish, medium-conviction view on OptumRx. He argues that the PBM model — of which OptumRx is a key part — profits through opaque markups and "spread taking," and that the vertical integration of PBMs with payers like UnitedHealth Group represents a structural market distortion. Friedberg sees meaningful reform risk, suggesting that removing PBMs from the system altogether would address a core problem in drug pricing. No other hosts weighed in, so no consensus or disagreement can be established beyond Friedberg's stance.

How they got there

FriedbergFriedberg1 take since May 17, 2025
BearishE228May 17, 2025

Friedberg flags OptumRx as part of a PBM oligopoly generating excess profits through markups and obfuscation, and argues the vertical integration of PBMs with payers is a structural distortion that faces serious reform risk.

They're allowed to be owned by the payer, which is crazy... there's a lot of obfuscation of the true cost of the drugs. There's a lot of markups, a lot of spread taking. And so if you took the PBMs out of the market, that would solve one1:35:42
iAbout these quotes
Quotes are machine-transcribed from the episode audio — use the Listen links to verify any take against the source, or the ⚑ link to report a problem. Takes marked unverified, low-conviction, or commentary-only never move stances, the index, or the funds.